|
|
|
|
|||||
|
||||||
Subject: Re: tidal heights calculations...
From: Lu Abel (lu.abel@XXX.XXX)
Date: Thu Jul 08 1999 - 16:19:01 EDT
At 08:38 AM 7/8/99 +0200, Russel Sher wrote:
>A friends of mine recently did a nav. theory course in which she said the
>'rule of twelfths' is no longer taught for tidal calculations. Instead,
>percentages are used. Has anybody heard of this? - Would that mean 10%, 15%,
>25%, 25%, 25% 10% instead of 1,2, 3, 3, 2, 1 (in twelfths)?
What course did your friend take?
I've taught Advanced Piloting (which covers tidal calculations) for the
Power Squadron for the past 15 years and I always teach the Rule of
Twelfths. It's so simple and handy it's almost a sin not to teach it --
for the 20 years I lived and sailed in New England I found it extremely
useful. (I'm not 100% certain it's actually in the current USPS text and
I've loaned out my copy so I can't check).
For those not familiar with the Rule of Twelfths:
If I draw a graph of the height of water vs time for waters (like New
England) where there are two highs and two lows per day of approximately
equal height, it looks like a sine wave with just over six hours between
high and low points. The Rule of Twelfths gives a very accurate way of
approximating that sine wave without actually using sines and cosines. It
says going from the time low water to high (or high to low) the tide will
have risen (fallen)
After one hour by one twelfth of its range
After two hours by an additional two twelfths
After three hours by an additional three twelfths
After four hours by an additional three twelfths
After five hours by an additional two twelfths
After six hours by the last one twelfth
This 1,2,3,3,2,1 pattern is trivial to remember.
How accurate is it? Here is a comparison of the percent of tidal rise over
a six hour period* as predicted by a sine wave and by the Rule of Twelfths.
Only in the first and last hours is it off, and then by only 2%!
hours sinusoidal twelfths
after low prediction prediction
(percent of range)
1 6.70 8.33
2 25.00 25.00
3 50.00 50.00
4 75.00 75.00
5 93.30 91.67
6 100.00 100.00
Sounds like Russ's friend was taught a 10,15,25,25,15,10 percent rule. It
too will produce correct results except for the first and last hour (where
it will be even less accurate than the Rule of Twelfths). I guess if one
has been sufficiently "metricated" that one can no longer divide by 12 this
might be better but to me the pattern is a lot harder to remember than
1,2,3,3,2,1.
Lu Abel
* Yes, the tidal period is closer to 6h 15m, but that's only another
percent or two of error in this prediction. Close enough when one realizes
how old most of bottom surveys are on our charts!
|