Check out the bookstore at IRBS.com
| Home | Mailing Lists | Bookstore | Weather | Tide Predictions | Bowditch |

Re: Universe of the ancient Greeks.

From: Bill (no email)
Date: Mon Mar 13 2006 - 17:05:46 EST

  • Next message: (no email): "Taking the mirror out of the equation"

    Lu wrote

    > Given the level of scientific knowledge, inquiry, and downright genius
    > among the ancient Greeks, I'm rather surprised that the idea of a
    > heliocentric universe didn't occur to one of them.

    It did indeed occur to one or more of them, Aristarchus of Samos. (Approx.
    300BC if memory serves--learned initially in a book obtained for me by
    Alex.) Long story short, the body politic was enamored with Plato et al so
    that was "wrong" in so many ways. That whole circle/sphere/uniform motion
    ran through Copernicus, and partially through Kepler et al. Problem being,
    no math or physics, and only approximate measurements, to prove/disprove
    theories. Not dissimilar to the state we can still find "advanced" physics
    in, IMHO.

    Ken of Celestaire mentioned Arthur Koestler's "The Sleepwalkers" on the list
    a while back. I find it a tough read, as I feel it plays to a well-rounded
    and highly-educated audience, but then takes certain liberties the intended
    reader might (should IMHO) find suspect. But if you can wade through the
    psychoanalysis ad nauseum and leaps, there is a good view of the history of
    astronomy, as well as other interesting information to be gleaned.

    Bill


  • Next message: (no email): "Taking the mirror out of the equation"



    | Home | Mailing Lists | Bookstore | Weather | Tide Predictions | Bowditch | Trawlerworld |