Two On A Big Ocean The Story of the First Circumnavigation
of the Pacific Basin
in a Small Sailing Ship


      

Other Books by
Hal Roth
| Home | Mailing Lists | Bookstore | Weather | Tide Predictions | Bowditch |

lv-ab: Re: Re: Anchoring Ordinances - no special rights

(no email)
Date: Mon Oct 09 2006 - 12:19:00 EDT

  • Next message: Arild Jensen: "RE: lv-ab: Re: Melbourne Anchoring Ordinance - derelict boats"

    > I see some merit in your arguments, but, unlike dirt dwellings,
    > someone buys waterfront for the view - and not necessarily one of a

    I do not see that as valid.

    Many people buy a land dwelling for the land view. Ask people
    overlooking city, or in the mountains, or frankly anywhere. They have
    no guarantee of control of their view. Many people in my region are
    finding small houses that used to be in their field of view are torn
    down and larger - taller - ones put up. When I lived in Baltimore my
    girlfriend had an office in a hirise overlooking the harbor. Until
    another hirise office was built in front of them.

    I see absolutely no valid reason for according people with a water view
    special rights to control of traffic in front of them. And if it ever
    comes to pass I hope hillside dwellers will sue for discrimination for
    lack of similar rights.

    Think about all that now. Really want to accord water view owners such
    legal status?

    > but were I to anchor out in one
    > location on a permanent basis, it wouldn't be in front of someone's
    > home out of respect.

    Why not you boat, rather than some "derelict". Would you not in fact be
    doing them a favor? If not you, who? Some party boat with rowdy owners?
    I vote for you.

    > As for living in view - our view of our
    > neighbours' homes in suburbia is generally of the front of their
    > house, their garden, the trunk of their car....one rarely sees one's
    > neighbours sitting in the front yard. On most of our boats, we live a
    > lot of our lives in plain view and not everyone wants to see that.>

    Man you need to get out and around more. I have lived in many places
    where I could see neighbors back yards, with people sitting around, and
    various other activities. As for front yards, what is different between
    adults sitting in a chair reading a book, talking or lounging vs kids
    playing? It's life, man. If people don;t want to see people they should
    live in caves.

    The attitude that waterfront owners should be accorded special rights
    and privileges to control their field of view is dangerous.

    A hillside dweller who wanted same would have to buy everything in their
    field of view - or else live in reality with the rest of us. Waterfront
    owners should be no different. Fortunately, as of the moment, they
    cannot buy the waterways. So let us NOT act as if they can.

    ___________________________________________________________________________
    || The Live-Aboard List : send a "subscribe" or "unsubscribe" request ||
    || in body of message to: ||


  • Next message: Arild Jensen: "RE: lv-ab: Re: Melbourne Anchoring Ordinance - derelict boats"



    | Home | Mailing Lists | Bookstore | Weather | Tide Predictions | Bowditch | Trawlerworld |