Jimmy Cornell - World Cruising Routes World Cruising Routes by Jimmy Cornell

      

Other books by Jimmy Cornell
| Home | Mailing Lists | Bookstore | Weather | Tide Predictions | Bowditch |

lv-ab: VHF communication ( was: Radar talk)

From: Arild Jensen (no email)
Date: Sun Sep 09 2001 - 11:10:21 EDT

  • Next message: Ben Ferguson: "Re: lv-ab: Radar talk"

    Several people said:
    "Commercial vessels often refuse to respond to my transmission on 16 or 13"

    Arild comments:

    Commercial vessels operating within Vessel Traffic Zones VTZ are
    required to monitor the specific channel used for that particular section
    of the zone.
    Ch 12, 13, and 14 are all used for this purpose.
    In the Great Lakes a special rule has even been fornulated that frees
    commercial ships from monitoring Ch 16.
    The justification being that the Coast Guard already covers the entire
    region, and both American and Canadian coast Gurad stations in effect
    provide duplication of coverage. They feel it is more important for the
    vessels to maintain a watch on the designated VTZ channel.
    Unless you check to see wwhich channel is in use, chances are you may
    well be calling on the wrong channel.
    And quite frankly, the amount of chit chat going on Ch 16 is enough to
    make any skipper turn doen the volume.

    BTW, not all commercial ships carry two radios so they can monitor more
    than one channel.
    SOLAS compliant radios are not the same as consumer VHF, so you cannot
    be sure they have a dual watch radio.

    An a final question.
    The tug was described as the "stand on" vessel. Yet in a later post the
    correspondent reported that finally the tug made a ninety degree turn to
    avoid a collision.

    Did I miss something or was the message garbled?
    If the tug was indeed the stand on vessel, the recreational vessel should
    have been making the course change; not the tug.

    I'm not trying to make excuses for poor manners or seamanship. However,
    some of the comments I see regarding commercial ships display a a total
    lack of awareness as to the situation that exists on the bridge of a
    commercial vessel, be it a tug or a 50,000 ton freighter. It would be a
    real eye opener to take a ride on a commercial ship, especially a foreign
    ship manned by a polyglot mix of nationalities. Even the officers
    sometimes only speak a dialect called "seaglish". A kind of pidgin
    english mixture of nautical terms, basic english and a mix of
    international words from many languages.
    Trying to talk to them by radio can be a very different experience.

    Cheers

    Arild
    ___________________________________________________________________________
    || The Live-Aboard List : send a "subscribe" or "unsubscribe" request ||
    || in body of message to: ||


  • Next message: Ben Ferguson: "Re: lv-ab: Radar talk"



    | Home | Mailing Lists | Bookstore | Weather | Tide Predictions | Bowditch | Trawlerworld |